billwear.github.io

The Design Spiral

Why design never runs in a straight line—and why that’s a feature, not a bug.

Updated 2025-09-23

What it is

The design spiral is the idea that engineering design moves in loops, not lines. You start with rough guesses, circle around to refine them, and with each pass, you tighten accuracy and detail. Rather than aiming for perfection on the first try, you orbit closer to the right answer.

Why it matters

How it looks in practice

  1. Sketch the concept (paper, whiteboard, CAD).
  2. Estimate feasibility: weight, cost, time, performance.
  3. Prototype or simulate.
  4. Test, measure, compare to requirements.
  5. Adjust assumptions and repeat.

Example

Ship design (classic use case):
- First spiral: length, beam, displacement, propulsion (rough).
- Second spiral: refine hull shape, stability analysis, weight balance.
- Third spiral: structure, detailed systems, safety margins.
- Final spirals: production drawings, cost checks, build plan.
      

The engineer’s mindset

The design spiral is not inefficiency—it’s realism. Every cycle brings surprises. The trick is to expect them, capture them, and spiral toward a better answer, faster.